News

Judge rebukes LSU lawyers over court filing language

The dispute stems from the SEC’s federal lawsuit over LSU’s attempts to play professional athletes.

Judge rebukes LSU lawyers over court filing language

A federal judge on Wednesday criticized LSU’s lawyers for accusing the SEC of “hallucinating” case citations. She directed them to seek removal of the term and prepare public statements expressing regret. Judge Annemarie Carney Axon also warned LSU attorney Bruce Rogers that another similar incident would bring sanctions to the fullest extent she could impose.

The dispute arose in the SEC’s federal lawsuit against LSU over the school’s attempts to play professional athletes. LSU’s football team did not roster the former professionals it had sought to sign, but the case continued. With LSU seeking dismissal, the SEC said private efforts to resolve the case had failed.

During Wednesday’s hearing in Birmingham, Rogers acknowledged that the cases cited by the SEC were legitimate. He argued that LSU used “hallucinated” because the cases’ holdings did not support the SEC’s position, rather than to suggest that opposing lawyers invented them.

Axon rejected that distinction and questioned whether attacks on another lawyer’s professional reputation qualified as legitimate advocacy. Rogers said they did not and told the judge he did not think attacking another member of the bar’s character was appropriate.

The SEC had described LSU’s wording as scandalous and professionally insulting. SEC attorney Tom Warburton told the court that the conference feared the accusation would spread publicly and cited multiple examples, including a USA Today story.

Rogers said LSU would ask the court that afternoon to remove “hallucinated” from its filing. Axon instructed him to acknowledge poor professional judgment in that request and called for public statements from Rogers, LSU and the Louisiana attorney general’s office, subject to her approval.

Why it matters

The language dispute adds another issue to a federal case LSU has sought to dismiss. The underlying lawsuit concerns LSU’s attempts to play professional athletes, although its football team did not roster the former professionals it sought to sign.

What to watch next

The next steps identified at the hearing were LSU’s request to remove the disputed term and public statements from Rogers, LSU and the Louisiana attorney general’s office for Axon’s approval.

More from the SEC desk

Comments

Loading…

The SEC Report

One conference, in your inbox every Tuesday.

Standings, the title race and one opinion on the SEC. No filler.

Free. Unsubscribe anytime. We never sell your email.